Broadcast messages for custom events : how to?

Mells

Hi community,

I am opening this thread to get some help (my previous thread was getting cluttered).

Do you know why isn't friend catching the message sent by enemy and how would you solve that?

-- main.lua   local mainGroup = Sprite.new() stage:addChild(mainGroup)   -- ENEMY local enemy = Enemy.new() mainGroup:addChild(enemy) enemy:setPosition(100, 50) enemy:setColorTransform(1, 0, 0, 1)   -- FRIEND local friend = Friend.new() mainGroup:addChild(friend) friend:setPosition(100, 600) friend:setColorTransform(0, 1, 0, 1)   -- INTERACTIONS -- ******************[ I want the friend to listen to the event ]************************* friend:addEventListener("enemyIsClose", friend.enemyAlertFunction, friend) -- ************************************************************************************   enemy:isClose()

-- classes.lua   -- CHAR Char = Core.class(Shape) function Char:init() self:setFillStyle(Shape.SOLID, 0xFFFFFF) self:beginPath() self:moveTo(0, 0) self:lineTo(500, 0) self:lineTo(500, 500) self:lineTo(0, 500) self:closePath() self:endPath() end   -- ENEMY Enemy = Core.class(Char) function Enemy:isClose() local flag = true if (flag) then closerEvent = Event.new("enemyIsClose") --with the specific keyword for the event. self:dispatchEvent(closerEvent) print ("Send message to Friend : Enemy is close") end end   -- FRIEND Friend = Core.class(Char) function Friend:enemyAlertFunction(event) print("Get message from Enemy : Enemy is close!") end

I can get "Send message to Friend : Enemy is close" to be printed but not "Get message from Enemy : Enemy is close!"

Why isn't friend catching the message sent by enemy?

Thank you for your help

alexzheng

the dispatcher and the register are not the same object in your code.

try

enemy:addEventListener("enemyIsClose", friend.enemyAlertFunction, friend)

Mells

@alexzheng that works well but in this case the friend is enemy dependent, right?
If the enemy is killed -> The friend won't be reacting to any other enemy.

I would like the friend to be able to listen to messages sent by any enemy, dynamically created.
So I thought I want to add the listener to the friend, and he would act on himself (run function).

So I don't want the enemy to act on the friend, I want the friend to listen and act.
Do you know how to do it?
Or maybe I'm mistaking the purpose of events and listeners?

alexzheng

You have to register the listener on each enemy you created.

I know what exactly you want is a broadcast event if available.

Mells

So are you suggesting that currently I can't achieve what I want? (listeners on friend, not enemy)

Broadcast events
I have made a research and found one of your suggestions for custom events :
Suggestion for custom events.

The discussion happened on december 2011 and @atilim said :

great idea. I've added this to the todo list.

I'd be interested to know if this is achievable or if I have been looking for something that is not currently possible

OZApps

@Mr. Mells, you can send a broadcast event, but for that you will have to intercept and manage it yourself. You can have a list of all the bojects that you want to send the broadcast message to and then using a loop, invoke that event / dispatch that message to them.

There are several ways to do that, even if you do not have dispatch events.

Mells

@OZApps,

but for that you will have to intercept and manage it yourself.

I really can't grasp the concept well : how can I intercept a broadcast event except from the object that dispatches the event himself (in my case, enemy)?
I don't undestand how objects communicate? I can see how enemy can order friend to act, but that's all.

Please take a look at that image below :


Case 1. Enemy (A) tells Friend (B) to Fight -> Achievable and I know how to do it

Case 2. Enemy (A) tells Friend (B) that he is close. Friend (B) then decides himself that he should fight -> It seems that it is not achievable from what I could understand from the people that commented on my threads.

Case 3. A middle man (C) checks the distance constantly between objects (A and and then informs and giver orders to friend (B) "Enemy (A) is close, You should Fight!" -> Is it what you are suggesting?
But in that case it seems that "middle man" is doing everything himself, and he is not "intercepting" events....

... right?
Sorry for asking again something that probably looks evident, but I was thinking that the ability to set up Case 2 would be simple and achievable.
I thought that Case 2 was exactly what the purpose of "listening" was.

bowerandy

@Mells, I apologize that I don't have time at the moment to understand exactly your predicament but I did read that you were looking for some form of broadcast events.

A couple of weeks back @atilim helped me out by posting the following recursive event dispatch idea:

-- save original stopPropagation function Event.__stopPropagation = Event.stopPropagation   -- reimplement stopPropagation function Event:stopPropagation() self.__isPropagationStopped = true self:__stopPropagation() end   function Event:isPropagationStopped() return not not self.__isPropagationStopped end   local function recursiveDispatchEvent(sprite, event) for i=sprite:getNumChildren(),1,-1 do recursiveDispatchEvent(sprite:getChildAt(i), event) end if not event:isPropagationStopped() then sprite:dispatchEvent(event) end end

Maybe you could use something like this to broadcast events to all objects on your stage. Bear in mind that, because this is in Lua, it will be significantly slower than the broadcast events implemented by the system and therefore may not be suitable if you have a lot of objects on the stage. Of course you could segregate your objects into layers and only recursively dispatch within a single layer.

The original thread is here:
http://www.giderosmobile.com/forum/discussion/comment/5755

Again, I apologise if this is not relevant to what you're looking for.

Best regards

Mells

@bowerandy first of all thank you for your help.
It seems a bit complex for my level, I will need time to understand if this is relevant to my problem or not
By the way, I really like your multistroke gesture recognition system that enhanced the great work provided by @ar2rsawseen.

In the meantime, I hope I can get other people to suggest a solution.

Javi

Hi @Mells, instead of using "mainGroup" to store a list of enemies and friends, I think the best solution is to have two lists: enemies and friends.

Maybe something like this?

CharactersList = Core.class() (...) function CharactersList:broadcastMessage(event) -- (send event to all characters in the list) end function CharactersList:getNearest(character) -- (return the character in the list nearest to character.position and the distance) end (...)     enemies = CharactersList.new() enemies:add(enemy_x) (...)     friends = CharactersList.new() friends:add(friend_x) (...)     -- (...loop to control the characters...) local enemy, distance = enemies:getNearest(friend) -- or: local friend, distance = friends:getNearest(enemy) if distance < x then -- send a message only to "friend" local friend_event = Event.new("ENEMY_CLOSE") friend_event.enemy = enemy friend_event.distance = distance friend:dispatchEvent(friend_event)   -- send a message only to "enemy" local enemy_event = Event.new("FRIEND_CLOSE") enemy_event.friend = friend enemy_event.distance = distance enemy:dispatchEvent(enemy_event) end if (...) -- send a message to all active enemies... enemies:broadcastMessage(Event.new("STOP_ALL")) if (...) (...)

Mells

Thank you @Javi, that was very helpful.